Hate Shopping? Here’s Why It Feels So Overwhelming (and What to Do This Holiday Season)
Most women who say they hate shopping don’t hate clothes. They don’t know where to start, which brands fit, or what size they wear.
Do you love to shop? Quite a few women I know say they dislike or even hate shopping. What I’ve learned over the last ten years of working with clients is that they typically don’t like shopping because they don’t know where to start. Believe me, I get it; it can be challenging and overwhelming, especially if you don’t know which brands fit you or what size you wear. The reality is there is no longer a sizing standard, and you could be one of three different sizes depending on the brand or store.
I know a lot of smart, successful, and capable women who run teams, businesses, and households, and they tell me they would rather do almost anything than walk into a store or scroll another sale page. So, don’t. This holiday season, skip the guessing game and shop with a short list you can build by assessing what’s in your closet and what’s not.
Why Shopping Feels Overwhelming
You don’t know where to start. A mall has hundreds of stores, and most have items that are cropped, show too much skin, or feel too young. Your inbox has dozens of sale emails, and without a plan, every option feels equally possible and equally exhausting.
It’s especially overwhelming if you are unsure which stores or brands fit you. One brand cuts for a straight frame, another for curves. One runs long, another runs short. Finding the few that work for your body takes trial and error most busy women don’t have time for.
To make it more challenging, retail has no real sizing standard. There is nothing wrong with your body; it’s the clothes. You might wear an 8 in one brand, a 10 in another, and a size L in a third. That isn’t your body changing. It’s the labels.
Instagram makes it look easy. You see a sweater that looks great on someone else, tap “buy,” and it arrives. Then it pulls across the shoulders, hits at the wrong spot, or doesn’t look like you. Your plate is full and way too busy to return it. So it sits in the bag, in the trunk of your car, or in the closet with the tags on.
In one survey of more than 2,000 US women, women estimated about 20% of their closet sits unworn, worth roughly $550. The most common reasons for not sending things back? No time, they couldn’t be bothered, or hadn’t gotten around to it.
That’s wasted money and wasted time. And none of it means you’re bad at style. It means you’ve been shopping without a guide.
Holiday Sales Make It Harder for You
The National Retail Federation expects shoppers to spend more than $1 trillion in November and December this year. The reality is, “deals” make it even easier to buy the wrong thing faster. For example, you grab a $20 or $40 top because it’s “on sale,” and it turns out that it doesn’t go with anything in your closet. Instead, choose and buy a top you know you’ll wear and can use to create two or three new outfits with what you already have in your closet.
The $20 or $40 top you grab because it’s on sale sits in the closet because you’re unsure what to wear it with, and it’s taking up precious space. It costs you time every morning when you’re trying to get dressed and have nothing to wear.
So you have two paths this season.
Path 1: Shop With a List (the Do-It-Yourself Way)
If you want to shop on your own, a list keeps the sales working for you.
- Assess and shop your closet first. Pull out the 10 pieces you wear most. Notice the colors, fits, and brands you reach for most. Start with those brands and decide whether you want something new or more of the same.
- Write down what you’re missing. It might be a pair of jeans that fit, a new blouse in a different color, or a nice blazer or outer layer that will expand your wardrobe. With every item you add to your list, make sure you can create new outfits with what you have. For example, a new blouse you can wear with your black pants, or a new pair of dark-wash jeans that will work with three tops you can wear for casual Friday. A jacket or cardigan you can layer over what you have that looks different from a blazer. My Capsule Wardrobe Starter Kit (3 tops, 3 bottoms, 3 layers, 1 dress or statement piece) helps you spot them.
- Order by fit, not by the number on the label. Order multiple sizes and try on the pieces; fit matters most, and the size on the label doesn’t. Check the measurements of a piece you love and compare them to the size chart. Ignore the number on the label.
- Run it through ABC. When you try on the pieces, ask yourself: How do you feel in it? Does it feel authentic? Will it let you show up on-brand? Does it give you confidence? If not, a great price doesn’t change the answer. That’s the ABC Style Method™ in action: Authentic, On Brand, Confident.
- Decide in 48 hours. When the order arrives, try it on with pieces you own. If you can’t build three outfits, put the return label on the box that day.
Path 2: Let Me Do the Shopping for You
My clients are busy and short on time. So when we work together, it starts in your closet. You and I assess what works and what doesn’t: the fits, colors, and pieces that make you feel confident, and the ones that never leave the hanger. Then there is a style inspiration look board with six to eight looks you can turn into twenty, thirty, sometimes forty different outfits. I take that list and shop the stores, brands, and sizes I know fit you. I do all the shopping; you try everything on at home with my guidance, keep what works, and I handle the rest (returns and exchanges done for you).
The result: the right pieces and outfits no matter where you’re going, whether that’s work, a client meeting, a networking event, date night, soccer with the kids, errands, or travel. I make it easy, so you see the results.
Your Next Step
Want to start on your own? Grab my free Style Shopping Quiz. It walks you through your shopping style and shows you where the real gaps are before the sales start.
Ready to hand it off? Book a Style Inspo Discovery call, and you can decide if a Curated Closet Session is the first step or if you’re ready for a full refresh with the Signature Style Reset. You don’t have to love shopping. You need a plan, or someone who does it for you.
I’m Elisa Ellis, a Dallas-based wardrobe stylist and consultant, and I’ve been featured or mentioned in The Wall Street Journal, CNN, The Guardian, and U.S. News & World Report. I am also the founder of Turnkey Style and the author of The Style Advantage: I Say What HR Can’t.
